This arises
from a comment made on an article about taxing wealth, a subject of bitter
debate across the political and economic board. A major problem is that wealth
now, that of not so long ago and that of earlier times are not the same. So how
and why to tax it becomes more complicated.
Essentially, at
one time a great deal of wealth was static. Think of the landed gentry, the
buildings and the gold, silver and the rest in the great churches and adorning
the rich and powerful, as well as sitting in the cellars of the Italian
bankers.
Then as
merchants and adventurers ventured across the world up to the 19th Century and
through to the 20th it became movable. Hence the drive to Empires with the aim
of moving as much of theirs as you could to become ours. In Europe it was at
the root of many of the wars, which certainly moved a lot of it about.
In recent
decades with the rapid development of communications technology, money creation
ideas and globalisation it is fluid, now you see it, now you don't as it moves
around the world faster than the time taken to fill an inkpot in the old days.
We have gone
from static to movable to fluid yet the philosophies of economics etc. as they
are translated into taxation policies are those essentially of one past or
another. We have not yet come up with a set of theoretical economics that can
cope with fluid monetary wealth in the global context.
Marx was a mid
to late 19th Century man who saw wealth as essentially static and so to be
shared by and with all while around him the banks were going broke as they
learned about movable wealth the hard way.
As the ups and
downs of this continued to plague economies for decades we come to Keynes, a
brilliant man and mind, who tried to advise us how best to deal with this. The
politicians as ever, preferring the easy and popular bits to the difficult
ones, made a mess of this on the whole.
Meanwhile the
techies in the attic were playing games on the new machines they were inventing
and began talking to each other over the ether.
It was not long before the
bankers who dealt with their accounts, invariably in the deepest red, realised
that just as the techies could control Mario The Plumber worldwide, they could
control money flows and holdings.
The rest is
history as we try to understand what is going on out there.
A fair bit of my money goes down the drain - indirectly.
ReplyDelete"we come to Keynes, a brilliant man and mind"
ReplyDeleteNot forgetting his brother Milton.